You Are a Whirlpool · Letter 29

fol. 36
  1. The five rules
  2. I
  3. II
  4. III
  5. IV
  6. V
Painters work on bright pictures at easels and benches in a courtyard beside an empty road that leads away
Painters work on bright pictures at easels and benches in a courtyard beside an empty road that leads away
Letter 29 · Rule V · Test

Meaning Is Something You Make

Nobody can hand you a purpose; the meaning is in the doing, the way the painting is in the painting.

A letter from Justin Hartfield. About 3 minutes.

There will be a night when you lie awake and ask what the point of it all is. It might come after a loss. It might come after a win that felt flatter than you thought it would. It might come on a plain Tuesday, at a job that pays fine and means nothing to you. It comes for almost everyone, and it isn’t a sign that something in you is broken.

People will tell you to find your purpose, as if it were hidden somewhere, like a key under a mat, and your job is to look harder. I don’t think it works that way. Nobody can hand you your purpose. Not me, not a book, not a quiz on your phone. Whatever you come to believe about the biggest questions, the meaning of a Tuesday gets made on Tuesday. I think meaning is made the way a painting is made: in the painting. You start, and it shows up on the canvas while you work.

That doesn’t mean nothing matters. It means the mattering is yours to do. This is rule five, with rule three close behind and a little of rule one.

First, you can’t think your way to meaning. You find out what matters to you the way you find out anything: you try things, and you watch what they leave behind. Some things you were sure would feel huge will feel like nothing once you have them. Some small things will stay with you for days. Teaching someone how to do a thing. Fixing a fence with a friend. Cooking for people who are hungry. The world answers, if you pay attention. Write down the answers.

Second, whatever you feed, grows. Meaning grows where you keep showing up. Almost nothing feels meaningful on the first day. An old friendship got its meaning one dinner at a time, over years. The same goes for a craft, a garden, a team, a family. If you’re waiting to feel it before you begin, you’ll wait a long time. The feeling comes after the doing, and it comes from the doing.

Third, look outward. You are a flow, not a sealed box, and what feels most worth doing usually has someone else in it. Notice how often the moments that mattered most in your life involved giving something: time, help, a meal, a hand. Don’t be surprised when the meaningful thing is also the hard thing. The two often come as a pair. A day that tires you out for someone you love can mean more than a week of easy fun.

You don’t need a grand plan for any of this. You need the next thing worth doing, and then the one after that.

Try this in the next week.

One evening, spend an hour making something for someone else. Cook them a meal. Fix the thing of theirs that’s been broken. Write them a real letter, by hand. On another evening, spend an hour just taking in: a show, a scroll through your phone, a snack on the couch. The next morning after each one, write a single line about how that hour sits with you now. By the end of the week you’ll have a good idea which kind of hour you want more of. And you’ll have already started making some.

One line to remember

Don’t wait to find the point. Pick up the brush and make some.

The earlier essay this letter grew from